Napoleon Bonaparte’s Failing Health at Dresden


Napoleon Bonaparte’s Failing Health at Dresden

9-1813-8-26-A4-2 (354049)

Napoleon in Dresden 1813 / Job

Befreiungskriege 1813-15 / Schlacht bei
Dresden 26./27. August 1813.
- N‰chtlicher Einzug Napoleons in
Dresden, gefolgt von Kriegsgefangenen
Offizieren der Alliierten. -
Farblithographie nach Illustr. von Job,
d.i. Jacques Onfroy de BrÈville (1858-
1931). Aus: G.Montorgueil, NapolÈon,
Paris (Boivin & Cie.) o.J.(um 1900),S.61
Paris, Privatsammlung.

NapolÈon ‡ Dresde 1813 / Job

Guerres de libÈration 1813-15 / Bataille
de Dresde les 26-27 ao˚t 1813.
- EntrÈe de NapolÈon ‡ Dresde ‡ la nuit
tombÈe suivi de gÈnÈraux ennemis prison-
niers. -
Lith. coul d'ap. ill. de Job (Jacques
Onfroy de BrÈville (1858-1931)).
In : G. Montorgueil, NapolÈon,
Paris (Boivin & Cie), vers 1900, p. 61.
Paris, Collection particuliËre.

Napoleon won a great victory at Dresden, but many historians believe his sudden illness—uncontrollable diarrhea and vomiting—prevented him from organizing an effective pursuit of the retreating Allied army. It underscores the fact that the emperor was plagued with bouts of ill health during the last decade of his life.

By Eric Niderost

Napoleon had occasional health problems before 1810. He seems to have experienced seizures one or two times, episodes that resembled epilepsy, although most medical historians feel that he did not have the disease—at least not a classic version of it. But in the main his health was good well into his thirties. “Work is my element,” Napoleon once declared. “I was born and made for work.” Eighteen-hour days were not uncommon, and in one celebrated incident he dictated 102 letters to several teams of secretaries over the course of two days.

With Declining Health Came Worse Performance on the Battlefield

Such activities were hardly the workload of a sick man. But Napoleon’s health took a turn for the worse after he reached the age of 40. He started getting chubby, a plumpness that soon became real fat. Official portraits, like David’s celebrated work, still showed the emperor with a trim waistline. But a few candid sketches—and a few surviving uniforms from the period—tell a different story.

The Battle of Waterloo

Gain new insight into the battle that brought the end of Napoleon’s rule in France.
Get your copy of Warfare History Network’s FREE Special Report,
The Battle of Waterloo

The Russian campaign provided the first real evidence of the emperor’s declining health. The night before the Battle of Borodino, Napoleon caught a bad cold, and this in turn triggered an attack of dysuria, a bladder condition. Doctor Mestivier, his personal physician, noted that Napoleon had a bad cough and was having trouble breathing. The doctor noted other symptoms as well. The emperor’s legs were swollen, his pulse was irregular, and he had periodic shivering fits. Napoleon himself complained to his valet of feeling sick—a startling admission for someone who rarely admitted any kind of weakness.

Napoleon’s illness may have affected his thought processes. He rejected Marshal Louis Nicholas Davout’s suggestion that they outflank the Russian forces, opting instead for an unimaginative and bloody frontal assault. For the most part Napoleon was passive, even lethargic, at Borodino, seemingly more interested in nursing his cold than in taking an active part in the unfolding drama.

Napoleon at Fontainebleau, March 31, 1814.

Napoleon at Fontainebleau, March 31, 1814.

As Napoleon’s health declined, so did his decision-making abilities, although he was still capable of real brilliance in planning and executing a campaign. But after 1810 there were more and more moments of indecision, of hesitation, than had been seen in earlier years. After the Battle of Maloyaroslavets in 1812, he agonized over which route the French army could take in retreat. The Russians under Marshal Mikhail Kutusov blocked the way to the southern route, which promised to offer more food. The Napoleon of old would have attacked without hesitation. Instead, the emperor avoided battle and chose the Smolensk-Moscow road, already devastated and stripped bare in the campaign.

The decision sealed the fate of the Grand Armée and turned a crisis into an unmitigated disaster. Ironically, Kutusov retreated shortly thereafter, leaving the door to the southern route open. The tragedy began even earlier, when Napoleon lingered too long in Moscow. Week after precious week was wasted while Napoleon mulled over his options. Wishful thinking had replaced hard-headed reality, as he convinced himself that somehow the czar would see reason and negotiate.

“My Mind Resists but My Body Gives in”

After the Dresden episode, the emperor never seemed to be fully well for the rest of the campaign. Once again, as in Russia, Napoleon seemed incapable of making up his mind. These bouts of indecision were accompanied by periods of despondency and outright depression. During the Battle of Leipzig, on October 17-18, 1813, Napoleon was seized with violent stomach pains, so terrible that he doubled up on his camp bed. “I feel bad,” the emperor complained. “My mind resists but my body gives in.” Some have attributed this particular attack to doudentitis, triggered in part by anxiety.

Periods of ill health dogged Napoleon for the rest of his days. He was indisposed the night of June 16-17, 1815, after his victory over the Prussians at Ligny, and wasted the morning of June 17 reviewing the troops instead of seeing how Marshal Michel Ney was doing with the Duke of Wellington at Quatre Bras.

Once again, the emperor’s ill health was accompanied by a curious lethargy that was ultimately fatal to his cause. Napoleon once declared that one had only a short time for war. Plagued by illness, lethargy, and indecision, Napoleon in his last decade illustrated the sad truth of his own assertion.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

Issue Previews

Evans Carlson & America’s First Special Operations Team

Evans Carlson & America’s First Special Operations Team

In 1942, Evans Carlson’s ‘Marine Raiders’ gained instant celebrity status as America’s first Special Operations team.

Eppa Hunton: Unsung Confederate Hero at the Battle of Ball’s Bluff

Eppa Hunton: Unsung Confederate Hero at the Battle of Ball’s Bluff

At the Battle of Ball’s Bluff, Colonel Eppa Hunton successfully rallied his command and played a key role in routing the Yankees.

Letters Home from the Battle of the Bulge

Letters Home from the Battle of the Bulge

During the 70th Anniversary of the Battle of the Bulge, Flint Whitlock shares a letter written by Sergeant David Warman to his family on Christmas Day in 1944.

After the Lincoln Assassination: The World-Wide Manhunt for John Surratt

After the Lincoln Assassination: The World-Wide Manhunt for John Surratt

John Surratt somehow escaped justice after the Lincoln assassination despite being intimately acquainted with John Wilkes Booth and other conspirators.

facebook gplus twitter youtube rss

Enter Your Log In Credentials

Forgot your Password?