Warfare History Network » Military Book Reviews for April 2005
Download FREE briefings. Have an account? Please log in. Text Size: A A A

Military Book Reviews for April 2005


Military Book Reviews for April 2005

Military book reviews from Warfare History Network.

Lt. Col. Harold E. Raugh, Jr. shares with us his military book reviews for the April 2005 issue of Military Heritage Magazine.

by Lt. Col. Harold E. Raugh, Jr.

The iconic portrait of General George Washington crossing the Delaware River in 1776 by Emanuel Leutze is familiar to many Americans. It represents dynamic leadership, battlefield courage, unity of purpose, and the willingness to risk everything in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds.

This watershed episode in nascent American history, the situation leading up to it, and the subsequent Battles of Trenton (December 26, 1776) and Princeton (January 3, 1777), are recounted in enthralling detail by David Hackett Fischer in Washington’s Crossing (Oxford University Press, New York, 2004, 576 pp., illustrations, maps, appendices, historiography, bibliography, notes, index, $35.00, hardcover). Fischer is University Professor at Brandeis University and the author of Albion’s Seed, The Great Wave, and Paul Revere’s Ride. Washington’s Crossing embodies the same high standards of research, analysis, and writing.

Fischer perceptively sets the stage by assessing the opposing forces and chronicling the events of the American Revolution in 1776. He shows convincingly that American fortunes and morale were at a low point. After the Declaration of Independence was signed on July 4, 1776, the Americans were defeated on Long Island (and elsewhere), abandoned New York, and retreated southwards through New Jersey. Washington’s army had lost 90 percent of its strength and withdrew across the Delaware River into Pennsylvania. Congress granted dictatorial powers to Washington and fled from Philadelphia to Baltimore.

Washington was grimly determined to strike the enemy before his army was further reduced by enlistment expirations, illness, and the severe winter weather. On Christmas night, 1776, he led a 2,400-man force by ferry across the treacherous Delaware River, about 10 miles north of Trenton, during a fierce blizzard. (Two additional crossings at other sites failed.) Shortly after dawn the next morning, the bedraggled but determined Americans attacked the 1,400 weary (not drunk, as frequently believed) Hessians garrisoning Trenton. Nearly 1,000 Hessians were killed or captured, with American losses considered “very trifling.” It was a resounding American victory.

Other British forces immediately advanced to Trenton. On January 2, 1777, the Continental Army faced a British force of 5,000 men, with another 2,500 British soldiers marching from Princeton to join them. That night, leaving its campfires burning, Washington’s army slipped away. The following morning, the Americans crushed the surprised British reinforcements. As a result, the British soon withdrew their garrisons from central and western New Jersey. British commanders and the public began to doubt their chances of success, and the outcome of the war shifted irrevocably.

This riveting book is based upon impeccable scholarship and is written in a lively and engaging manner. Fischer makes superb use of accounts not only by American soldiers, but of British and Hessians as well. His analysis and descriptions of the conflict at the tactical, operational, and strategic levels of war offer the reader greater understanding of the American Revolution. Significantly, Fischer emphasizes that the American Revolution was a “war of contingency,” “in the sense of people making choices, and choices making a difference in the world.”

These astonishing American victories had repercussions reaching far beyond the battlefield. Fischer shows that “the campaign saw the evolution of a new style of military leadership, as well as a new, American ethic of warfare, that helped to turn the tide of public opinion in America and around the world.” This book is an outstanding study of the evolution and practice of Washington’s military leadership and of the American Revolution.

Recent and Recommended

Gettysburg: The Meade-Sickles Controversy, by Richard A. Sauers

The pivotal Union victory at the Battle of Gettysburg, July 1-3, 1863, continues to be surrounded by controversy. In this deeply researched and tightly argued study, Dr. Richard A. Sauers challenges one of the most contentious issues of the battle. This dispute was between Major General George G. Meade, commander, Army of the Potomac, and Major General Daniel E. Sickles, 3rd Corps commander (and the first person in American history found not guilty of murder due to temporary insanity). It involved Sickles’ advance of the 3rd Corps forward of the Union lines—whether on Meade’s orders or against them—which exposed the Union left flank. This advance led to the hard-fought engagements at the Wheatfield and the Peach Orchard. A later report stated that Sickles’ advance was “an error which nearly proved fatal in the battle.” Moreover, Sickles’ corps did not occupy the strategically important Little Round Top.

Sickles was seriously wounded and immediately began to tell his own version of events, which contained fabrications and became further self-serving and embellished over the years. Sauers has dissected this controversy and concludes that Sickles did in fact disobey orders and jeopardized the Union position, as well as the possible outcome of the battle. Sauers’ analytical study should be the last word on this enduring controversy.

In Brief

Fortress Alcatraz: Guardian of the Golden Gate, by John Arturo Martini

While “The Rock” of Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay is well known as the notorious former federal penitentiary, it also served as a U.S. Army installation from 1850 until acquired by the Department of Justice in 1934. Retired National Park Service historian and former Alcatraz park ranger John A. Martini has written in rich detail a lively and fascinating history of the quarter-mile long, 500-feet wide island fortress. Construction of the artillery batteries and emplacement of permanent guns was completed in 1860. They were designed to overlap fields of fire from Fort Point and Lime Point Bluff, on either side of the Golden Gate. By 1866, with 111 mounted artillery pieces, Alcatraz reached its peak as a military fortification. Defenses were rebuilt after the Civil War, frequently using soldier-convict labor. The bastion was converted from a harbor-defense fort to a military prison in 1907, and to a U.S. “Disciplinary Barracks” in 1915. Profusely illustrated with historical and contemporary photographs and drawings, this is an excellent historical overview of Alcatraz Island, during the Civil War the U.S. Army’s “greatest fortress west of the Mississippi.”

Barbarians, Marauders, and Infidels: The Ways of Medieval Warfare, by Antonio Santosuosso

The medieval ages generally comprise the period from the “fall” of the Roman Empire in the fifth century (476 A.D.) to the end of the Hundred Years’ War and the capture of Constantinople a millennium later, in 1453. This was a violent era of almost continual warfare caused by religious, ethnic, and cultural friction. In this impressive and vividly written study, Professor Antonio Santosuosso surveys the causes, conduct, changes, and impact of warfare throughout this era. This book is divided into four parts. The first covers roughly the years 476-814, when from the ruins of the Roman Empire emerged “barbarian” kingdoms that evolved into the Carolingian empire in Western Europe. The second section covers basically the same period but focuses on the rise of Islam and its expansion through the Middle East, across North Africa, and into Spain. The empire-building West from 800-1,300, a period of especially savage warfare that included the establishment of feudalism and the Crusades, forms the third part of this volume. Finally, warfare from the zenith of the Middle Ages, c. 1,300, to the closing years of the 15th century, is chronicled and assessed. This immensely informative book, a main theme of which is “the idea that medieval war was carried out for God, personal profit, and honor,” makes a superb contribution to the study of warfare during the Middle Ages.

Interpreters with Lewis and Clark: The Story of Sacagawea and Toussaint Charbonneau, by W. Dale Nelson

The bicentennial of the 1804-1806 Lewis and Clark Expedition has sparked renewed interest in this momentous military saga. The mission of the Corps of Discovery was to explore the vast newly acquired 800,000-square-mile Louisiana Purchase. Moreover, the expedition was to find and map an overland route from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean. In this era of political correctness, the Indian woman Sacagawea has been singled out as the experienced guide largely responsible for the expedition’s success. While this is a romantic and appealing image, the expedition’s journals do not support it. Sacagawea’s alleged role has greatly overshadowed that of Toussaint Charbonneau, a French-Canadian fur trader who was actually hired as the expedition’s interpreter—and was Sacagawea’s husband. Author W. Dale Nelson has shown that Charbonneau (whom Lewis called “a man of no peculiar merit”) was a valuable asset to the expedition, interpreting with various Indian tribes encountered, negotiating for horses and supplies, and other tasks. Nelson also explores the various versions of Sacagawea and of her son, Jean Baptiste Charbonneau’s, life. This well researched and superbly crafted book, revising aspects of the Lewis and Clark Expedition, is a real page-turner.

Sacrificed at the Alamo: Tragedy and Triumph in the Texas Revolution, by Richard Bruce Winders

Dr. Richard Bruce Winders is historian and curator of the Alamo. He has written an interesting and provocative monograph of events leading up to and the actual siege and battle of the Alamo garrison in 1836. Rather than focus on minutiae, such as Davy Crockett’s headgear, Winders’ sweeping narrative focuses on larger historical and political movements and the two countries where they took place, the United States and Mexico, and where they intersected: Texas. The situation was ripe; Winders suggests that “the context for the revolt is a larger civil war that was occurring in Mexico.” The larger issue was Federalism versus Centralism, with much of its focus in San Antonio de Bexar, a key crossroads town that had served as the governmental seat of Texas under Spanish administration. The Mexican government of Santa Anna needed to quell the American and Tejano (native born Mexicans living in Texas) rebels in Bexar and reassert its authority. The events leading up to the actual battle of the Alamo at Bexar are a study in contradictions, with Sam Houston reinforcing the bastion while doubting the town could be defended, revealing a political rift between the governor and General Council of Texas. In this perceptive and well written study, Winders concludes that, “Although killed by soldiers of Mexico’s Centralist government, the Bexar garrison [the Alamo] was doomed by the political infighting that raged among Texas’s revolutionary leaders.”

If the Gods are Good: The Epic Sacrifice of the HMS Jervis Bay, by Gerald L. Duskin and Ralph Segman

The 1940 naval engagement pitting the armed merchant cruiser H.M.S. Jervis Bay against the German pocket battleship Admiral Scheer was a true David-and-Goliath struggle. The Jervis Bay was an old cargo ship with a few obsolete guns bolted to its deck. In late October 1940, the Jervis Bay began escorting the 38-ship convoy HX84 from Halifax bound for England carrying cargo crucial to the island’s survival. On November 5, 1940, while halfway across the frigid North Atlantic, convoy HX84 was attacked by the Admiral Scheer, armed with 11-inch and 5.9-inch guns. Upon identifying the enemy warship, Jervis Bay Captain E.S.F. Fegen dutifully and aggressively ordered his ship to attack the Scheer and the merchant ships in the convoy to scatter. After a short gunnery duel in which the Jervis Bay was outranged, the British ship was pounded and set ablaze. It continued to fire on the Scheer and distracted the German ship for almost three hours before it was sunk. Fegen, who received the Victoria Cross posthumously for his gallant leadership, sacrificed his ship so most of the convoy could escape and deliver its precious cargo to England. This is a surprisingly interesting and riveting book, a fitting tribute to Captain Fegen and the Jervis Bay.

Devil’s Game: The Civil War Intrigues of Charles A. Dunham, by Carman Cummin

Charles A. Dunham was the “consummate chameleon” during the Civil War. He created at least nine identities (and probably more) for himself, moving effortlessly from one to another and from North to South, concocting lies to facilitate his movement. In the North, Dunham was known as Sandford Conover and Isaac Haynes. His characters in the South included the convalescing Colonel James Watson Wallace and Colonel George Margrave, “one of the most cool and reckless villains in the Confederacy.” He was a spy, a forger, and a “master of dirty tricks,” writing different articles for newspapers under various names, generally criticizing the Confederates and Northern Peace Democrats. He even had his invented characters accuse each other of heinous crimes and then wrote about them. Perhaps Dunham’s greatest notoriety stems from his testimony—later discredited—against the Lincoln assassins, swearing the conspiracy began in Richmond. His statements helped lead to the execution of John Wilkes Booth, and suggest he may have been operating under the patronage of Secretary of War Edwin Stanton or another powerful politician. Journalism professor Carman Cummings has conducted extensive research to shed light on Dunham’s shadowy life and activities. While a number of questions remain unanswered, this is a compelling historical Civil War detective story.

The Road to Kabul: The Second Afghan War, 1878-1881, by Brian Robson

For much of the nineteenth century, Afghanistan was the pawn in the “Great Game” of colonial expansion pitting czarist Russia against imperial Britain in central Asia. In 1878, British forces invaded Afghanistan to forestall Russian encroachment on the frontier of India, Intense fighting took place in the mountain passes, causing the Afghan leader to flee and his son to sign a treaty with the British. Peace was short-lived, as rebellious Afghan soldiers killed the British resident in Kabul in September 1879 and another British force marched into Afghanistan. After victories at Charasia, Sherpur, and Ahmed Khel, and a devastating defeat at Maiwand, the British routed the Afghan tribal army at Kandahar on September 1, 1880, and ended the Second Afghan War. This well written and fast-paced study, incorporating interesting primary source documents and participant accounts, presents “some of the most vivid contrasts—of heroism and sacrifice, incompetence and folly, disastrous defeat and glorious victory” in British colonial warfare. It is also a superb example of inept attempts at “regime change” in Afghanistan and their far-reaching consequences.

A Military History of Sovereign Hawai’i, by Neil Bernard Dukas

This engrossing book makes a truly original contribution to military history. Few know that Hawaii was annexed by the United States only in 1898, and that prior to this time, Hawaii was a sovereign kingdom. Author Neil Bernard Dukas divides his fascinating military history of Hawaii into two parts. The first section focuses on the Hawaiian warrior (“koa”), and his development based upon Polynesian culture and values. The 18th century Hawaiian society both “endorsed and enjoyed battle,” but also “set controls to limit battle’s carnage.” Other topics covered include traditional Hawaiian weapons, recruiting and training, mobilization and organization for war, battle dress, battlefield tactics, and the ethos of the koa. Part 2, “Soldiers of the Crown,” commences with King Kamehameha’s nominal unification of the Hawaiian Islands in 1796. After 1815, Hawaii was subject to foreign incursions and the warrior state declined. Russians, Argentines, Britons, and Americans traded with the Hawaiians and challenged their independence, forcing the Hawaiians to form militia units for national defense. Finally, during a period of instability and at the beginning of the 1898 Spanish-American War, the United States annexed Hawaii. Dukas’ superbly researched, elegantly written, and handsomely produced study of Hawaii’s military history deserves a large audience.

Battle of the Piave: Death of the Austro-Hungarian Army, 1918, by David Raab

The unprecedented slaughter of trench warfare on the Western Front has come to characterize the popular image of World War I. There were, however, many “peripheral” operations conducted, in East Africa, Gallipoli, Salonika, Palestine, Mesopotamia, and Italy, designed to break the stalemate of the Western Front. One of the bloodiest theaters was the Italian Front that stretched from the Alps to the Adriatic Sea. While this slim book is entitled Battle of the Piave, only one cursory six-page chapter covers this important June 1918 battle. Other chapters superficially chronicle the Battles of the Isonzo, Caporetto, and Vittorio Veneto. There are only 50 pages of text in this monograph, 40 pages of poor quality illustrations and maps, and 18 pages of endnotes. The many seemingly unnecessary endnotes reveal a heavy reliance on secondary source books. While the author apparently wanted to write a definitive history of the Battle of the Piave, this book falls far short of that goal.

America in World War I: The Story and Photographs,
by Donald M. Goldstein and Harry J. Maihafe

This interesting volume is a valuable pictorial presentation of American participation in World War I. There are 12 chapters in this book, covering U.S. Army soldiers training and deploying for combat in Europe, the U.S. Navy’s ships and sailors at sea, and the new and rapidly evolving airplanes, balloons, and aerial warfare. One chapter is devoted to “The Home Front” and the conditions and contributions of Americans supporting the war effort. Two chapters showcasing American military operations in Europe are 9, “The Crucial Months: March-July 1918,” and 11, “Meuse-Argonne, the Final Push: August-November 1918.” One of the most interesting chapters is 6, “The Tools of War,” which depicts the increasingly lethal rifles, machineguns, artillery, flamethrowers, and chemical weapons of the frontline adversaries. The last chapter, 12, “The Aftermath,” discusses the Versailles Treaty and its consequences for postwar Europe. A strength of the narrative is that it contains numbers that refer to the relevant photographs. On the other hand, the general nature of the narrative contains factual oversimplifications and errors. This photographic history is a fine primer on American soldiers and participation in “the war to end all wars.”

Lawrence of Arabia: An Encyclopedia, by Stephen E. Tabachnik

T.E. Lawrence, a leader of the Arab revolt against the Turks in World War I that spawned his quasi-autobiographical Seven Pillars of Wisdom, continues to intrigue and interest historians and others. Stephen E. Tabachnick, who has previously written about “Lawrence of Arabia,” has produced an encyclopedia with more than 800 entries to help one navigate through the myriad facts and fabrications of Lawrence’s life, personality, and writings. From “Aaronsohn, Aaron” to “Zionism,” these entries include such topics as “Lawrence’s knowledge of Islam, the details of his military campaigns, his legacy in film and popular culture, his family members and acquaintances, his biographers, and important book dealers, collectors, and scholars interested in his writings.” The wide variety of the entries and the general information provided, coupled with additional references and a worthwhile bibliography, far outweigh the volume’s numerous small factual errors and inadequate index. Every Lawrence scholar and enthusiast will want this indispensable encyclopedia on his bookshelf.

Some Survived: An Eyewitness Account of the Bataan Death March and the Men Who Lived Through It, by By Manny Lawton

“Those eyewitness stories, put together with similar ones from other prisoners,” observed Manny Lawton, “painted a hideous picture of savage and inhumane brutality unbelievable in modern times.” Lawton was a 23-year-old U.S. Army captain serving as an adviser to the 1st Battalion, 31st Infantry, Philippine Army, in 1941-1942. After months of resistance, his unit was ordered on April 8, 1942, to prepare to surrender to the overwhelming Japanese onslaught. The following morning, the infamous Bataan Death March began. It was “a forced six-day, sixty-mile trek under a broiling tropical sun during which approximately eleven thousand men died or were bayoneted, clubbed, or shot to death by the Japanese.” But this was only the beginning of the unimaginable hell on earth that Lawton and his comrades would experience in over three harrowing years as Japanese prisoners-of-war (POW). Lawton describes in poignant detail, with a moving sense of realism and immediacy, his POW experiences, including transport on a “hell ship” to Japan. His account is interspersed and rounded out with the recollections of fellow POWs. While the cruelty and inhumanity of the Japanese can never be forgotten, Lawton’s story shows the triumph of the human spirit over unspeakable adversity.

This article is from the April 2005 issue of WWII History Magazine. If you would like to read the rest of this and other articles, visit our order page to see which digital editions we have on offer.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

Issue Previews

Reassessing Rommel: Anti-Nazi Hero or Opportunist?

Reassessing Rommel: Anti-Nazi Hero or Opportunist?

Seventy years later, should the “Desert Fox” be considered an anti-Nazi hero or a faithful soldier turned opportunist?

USS Potomac: FDR’s White House on the Water

USS Potomac: FDR’s White House on the Water

President Franklin D. Roosevelt took the bullet-proofed yacht the USS Potomac on two of the greatest diplomatic missions of WWII.

Il-2 Sturmovik: The Soviet’s Deadly Tank Killer

Il-2 Sturmovik: The Soviet’s Deadly Tank Killer

The Soviet Air Force’s Ilyushin Il-2 “Storm Bird” took a heavy toll in German armor on the Eastern Front.

“Love” Company in the Vognes Mountains

“Love” Company in the Vognes Mountains

The author, a rifleman in “Love” Company, 399th Infantry Regiment, 100th Infantry Division, recalls brutal winter combat on the French-German border.

facebook gplus twitter youtube rss

Enter Your Log In Credentials

Forgot your Password?